1350+ Shelter Island Holiday Rentals & Private Villas

Find Family-Friendly Holiday Rentals in or near Shelter Island

Explore a diverse selection of more than 1350 holiday rentals in Shelter Island with SunSki Resorts. Our holiday homes offer everything you need for a comfortable stay near Shelter Island, CA.

Whether you're in search of luxurious villas, furnished homes, unique condos, cozy cottages for a romantic escape, spacious apartments for family vacations, or stylish accommodations for business trips, we've got you covered. Our holiday rentals boast top-notch amenities including indoor/outdoor swimming pools, fully-equipped kitchens, gyms, hot tubs, high-speed Internet, and more.

Planning a trip to Shelter Island with your family or a group? Our holiday accommodations ensure a memorable experience for all. With plenty of options available for families, large groups, or private owner accommodations for short or long trips, you'll find the perfect fit. We also offer pet-friendly holiday rentals, catering to all members of your travel party. Book your preferred vacation rental in Shelter Island with SunSkiResorts and enjoy a seamless booking experience today.

Show more
Show less

Frequently Asked Questions About Shelter Island Holiday Rentals

There are a lot of options in Shelter Island. If you plan on staying in the Shelter Island area, consider making a reservation for a few nights at one of these properties as these have been rated the top Holiday Home Rentals in Shelter Island:

There are many holiday rentals available in Shelter Island; however, here are a few of the most popular holiday homes listed in Shelter Island on our website:
At SunSkiResorts most of our places to stay are perfect for families. Check out the complete list of holiday homes in Shelter Island to find one that works for you.
Yes, there are 1350 self-catering family homes and holiday rentals in Shelter Island.
There are more than 1350 luxury holiday homes in or near Shelter Island, according to 2025 data from SunSkiResorts. Consider these homes for your next holiday:
Yes, there are 1350 pet friendly rentals that are available in Shelter Island.